Singer/Songwriter Neil Jackson in a live solo acoustic session
The "large-diaphragm condenser" class of 2008 was loaded with gorgeous and innovative contenders, and we here at PAR would like to revisit the top five "LDCs" we reviewed to compare them in close proximity. Note that this is the first installment of our new Session Review series —not a clinical "shootout," per se, but parallel testing and evaluation to seek the best applications for these proven winners and suggest their comparative strengths in the real world.
With the enlistment of some great local clients, The Lights Fluorescent (a talented group with a couple of engineers for members), we configured our usual tracking setup. Then we began adding our test subjects to the setup, finding where each mic improved upon (or detracted from) our "baseline." The results were sometimes surprising and hugely informative, providing comparative info that is very hard to find under average (i.e., rushed) studio conditions.
Neumann TLM 67
Neumann TLM 67
The TLM 67 ($3,858 list) offers the K67 capsule, three patterns, -10 dB pad, an EA 87 suspension mount, and case. Its big, warm sound screamed U 67, even without a tube present. Ty Ford's original review [PAR October 08] proved to be extremely accurate, as we both found the 67 to have an unhyped bottom end, smooth mids and a classic, comparatively understated top end. This top end was extended, but never strident or brittle. There was a bump in the low mid response that proved to define the character of this mic; somewhere around 300 Hz, this bump was sometimes essential and other times detrimental.
The 67 excelled in drum-kit reproduction with a punch in the lows, without tubbiness and with a smoothness of highs that needed no EQ (highly recommended for overheads or room mics). Electric guitar was very nice and smooth, but that low-mid bump often needed subtractive EQ; it is good for jazz or clean tones, not so good for heavy distortion or "carved out mids" type tracks.
This mid bump was interesting on bass guitar, but only for bass lines that required lots of mid definition. Vocals were similarly hit or miss. For these sessions, that low-mid bump made nasal vocal qualities unbearable, but provided some thickness and body to our female vocals — a highly recommended app.
JZ Black Hole BH-1
JZ Black Hole BH-1
The BH-1 multi-pattern condenser ($2,295 list) has some very interesting design qualities, with the rectangular hole in its center being the most obvious. The provided shockmount is attractive, but not as effective as hoped. PAR reviewer Russ Long had success with it [PAR July 08], but its use perplexed me. I never could get the mic to sit still, as minor movement jarred it out of position and the windscreen made the ensemble top-heavy and unstable.
In our sessions, the Black Hole BH-1 offered a lean bottom end and aggressive top. This frequency response was too crisp for drums, with sizzling highs and insufficient bottom. This tonality worked better for electric guitar amp and was very nice on detailed acoustic guitar work. We were most surprised with the BH-1 on bass guitar amp; its lean bottom allowed the perfect definition of low notes without muddiness or boom with great high string detail — a very modern, aggressive bass sound.
Vocals with the BH-1 proved to be a matter of taste. Here, its aggressive top was simply overbearing to me (on either men or women), although if you like sibilance and pronounced definition for stylistically engineered vocal sounds, you may justifiably feel otherwise. In omni, the BH-1's qualities all became positive on a group backup vocal track with its great detail and room air.
Violet Flamingo ME
Violet Flamingo ME
The Flamingo ME ($6,990 list) is eyecatching, yes, but it was the ear-shaped diaphragm and its "vented" gold sputtering that intrigued us. Cardioid only (its sole drawback), the ME has an inviting sound with a full and accurate bottom, smooth velvety top and a touch of lowmid emphasis. This response emphasized snare and toms, while taming cymbals and rounding out transients: It was beautiful.
The ME performed predictably on guitar amp, although you'll probably need some EQ to add top and carve those low mids a bit. Same thing goes for bass guitar, where the 200 Hz emphasis may help or hinder you. In our original review, Russ Long loved the ME on male and female vocals [PAR January 08], and I completely agree. It may be too dark for basses or mumblers, but the ME's tube and transformer precisely tamed harsh consonants and aggressive rock yells yet maintained definition — all this without a touch of unwanted sibilance.
One of the costliest microphones we have recently reviewed [PAR March 08], expectations were understandably high for the Brauner VMA ($9,719 list). It is gorgeous in its craftsmanship, most notably in the cylindrical windscreen, allowing up-close singing for groups in omni or duos in figure eight. The power supply of the VMA was particularly nice with patterns of cardioid, wide cardioid, hyper-cardioid, figure eight, and omni — all continuously variable. The VMA employs the capsule/electronics of the original VM1 alongside a second capsule (not just filters) for a "classic" mode with conservative top end and vintage tonality. Essentially, it is two microphones sharing a body; as a result, its versatility significantly softens the blow of the price.
Across all tests conducted, the VMA was either our top choice or very close to it. The reason? It offered a palpable sense of realism to its tracks, very accurate and extremely nuanced. This lack of color allowed faithful reproduction of most any source placed before it. Bass response was very extended, but without hype or emphasis bumps; this made the VMA my top choice for bass guitar amp. Drums via VMA were faithful and accurate, with quick transients and no discernible distortion. Vocalists of all varieties should find success with the VMA; its neutral flexibility allows a variety of vocal sounds with some minor EQ. The only app that didn't immediately impress us was on electric guitar, where the VMA exposed some undesirable traits in our guitar setup. Matched with the right rig, I'm sure the VMA could excel.
But the VMA "classic" mode, you ask? Yes, it is distinct, and very desirable. With its thicker bottom and sculpted, musical top, I loved this mode for lead vocals and "normal" mode for BGVs.
Unfortunately, the U77 ($3,495 list) didn't make it into session evaluation in time for initial drum, bass, and guitar tracking. Such a shame, as personal testing revealed an extremely musical mic that was simultaneously very flattering and yet very naturally accurate on most any source. Although its classic "big 3" patterns make it versatile enough for many instrument apps, I'm in love with this mic for vocals. Like the Flamingo ME, original reviewer Dan Wothke [PAR June 08] found the U77 very desirable for both men and women vocalists; that's a rare quality, and I strongly support Dan's findings. Lead, BGV, or group, loud or tender: The U77 shines in most vocal situations.
Berliner U 77
The U77 is also a first pick for acoustic instruments. Its inherent balance, natural transients and ever-soslight high-frequency emphasis worked nicely on acoustic guitar, piano, or most any natural source where realism is your goal.
On VO Work
I did some commercial spots with male voiceover artist Charles Curcio and found something likable about all five of our mics. Ultimately, we chose the Neumann TLM 67 for its smooth, yet articulate top end, with minimized sibilance problems. Low frequencies were flattering without any undue girth while plosives were never an issue, even at really loud levels.
The Brauner VMA in classic mode was our second choice for this VO session; it was wonderfully detailed and natural, if ever so slightly strident on hard consonants. The Berliner U77 was nearly as likable as the TLM 67, except for a little missing "chestiness." I must say, however, that the U77 would be my "best-all-around" choice if I could buy only one mic for all VO work. The Flamingo ME was very warm and supple; I would prefer it with female voice artists. The Black Hole BH-1 had the most top end of any mic tested here — great for definition on deeper voices, but too sensitive to plosives in cardioid. Even with two pop screens employed, we had to switch to omni to get suitable results.
With this collection, I also knocked out (live) singer/songwriter sessions and predictably got some great tracks. The performer, Neil Jackson, sings loudly with an edgy quality, and the Flamingo ME was the ideal transducer for its rounding qualities. The original mode from the VMA was our primary choice for acoustic guitar (with its welcomed linearity), coupled with either the U77 or the Black Hole BH-1 for some exciting sizzle. With the TLM 67 picking up room ambience, the result was slightly enhanced reality without a dreadful DI anywhere in sight.
Here, the top performer overall was the Brauner VMA for its incredible accuracy, "dual mic" flexibility, and supreme package of accessories. Russ Long gushed about the VMA, calling it "stunning," and I definitively agree. The Violet Flamingo ME was an unexpected favorite with smooth reproduction and a sonic quality geared for the environment of digital recording. The Neumann TLM 67 was very impressive, with its own smooth sonics and a lack of harshness, although its mid bump proved to be problematic in some apps. The Berliner U77 offered the most overall flexibility and was simply stellar on vocals and acoustic instruments. Finally, the JZ Black Hole BH-1 is an extremely desirable transducer hindered only by a questionable shockmount and an overstated top end, which many may find more desirable than I do.
Rob Tavaglione owns and operates Catalyst Recording in Charlotte, NC. He welcomes your comments, questions, and inquiries firstname.lastname@example.org.